Friday 23 January 2009

The Singaporean Worker (vs the French)

Having had the chance to work in a French bank for 5 months alongside the notoriously fun and leisure loving French, it is perhaps only natural that I put forth some observations here.

The French (excluding those snobbish types living in Paris) have a wicked sense of humor - sometimes judged a tad crude or sexual. But one thing is for sure, once they are comfortable with you, they can be ridiculously funny, made even funnier when they try their jokes in English. They are best mixed with a relaxed attitude towards work, and a take-it-easy spirit. Oh yes, and they will try their utmost to include you in their discussions by speaking in English and if they ever break into their native French, they apologise for it. This is truely something I can take back with me.

The generous welfare benefits for the French employee are another stark contrast to what we have in Singapore. A typical employee in a financial institution gets up to 45+10 (compulsory+voluntary) days of annual leave to compensate them for working longer that the stipulated 35 hours a week. The 9+3 months of paid maternity+paternity leave is another feature of the generous welfare given to the French. Not forgetting also the free healthcare and education right up to university levels. The costs of this all? A rather breath-taking tax rate of as high as 45%, not including the various fees, muncipal taxes, etc. And a shrinking (in deficit currently) social benefits pool which could basically mean that current generation may not get to enjoy the full pensions promised to them in retirement. So you gain some, you lose some.

Whilst talking to a group of them over lunch once, I asked what they thought of their equivalent in Singapore. What's said was not surprising at all - their Singaporean counterpart works really hard and long hours and has twice their workload. And I believe, more than likely not paid any more than they are. [There are 1.5 Singaporeans in the team supporting Asia and sometimes NY, compared to 4 French in the team. The Singaporeans who get off work at 10pm SG time will be heartbroken to know that the French office is almost empty by 6pm FR time]

So how do we explain this? Paying a premium for a group of workers who seemingly have less work over another? Perhaps the French are indeed more productive? Perhaps it is a lifestyle thing? Or perhaps it is due to the fact that it is a French bank?

There's an ideal amongst the French and it is that they believe everyone should be entitled to a certain quality and standard of living which from my vantage is quite high (you got to forgive a Singaporean who grew up in a three-room HDB flat and living in the heartlands). So to them, life and time outside work is extremely important and they will not spend more time than what they are paid.

I guess for Singaporeans, like one senior minister once remarked, working hard is something we cannot shake off...

1 comment:

Unknown said...

Interesting fact to know the vast difference between working culture of Singaporeans and French people.